Resources

5 Biggest Mistakes New York Homeowners Make When Choosing a Roof Color

Written by Robertson Roofing & Exteriors | Sep 16, 2024 2:17:44 PM

Choosing the right roof color for your home is more important than many homeowners realize. The color you choose not only impacts your home’s curb appeal but also affects energy efficiency and even long-term maintenance costs. For New York homeowners, where the weather can range from sweltering summers to harsh winters, making the right choice is essential. In this blog, we’ll walk through the five biggest mistakes homeowners make when choosing a roof color—and how to avoid them.

1. Ignoring the Impact of Climate

New York experiences a wide variety of weather conditions, from scorching summers to frigid winters. The color of your roof can have a significant impact on your home’s energy efficiency. Lighter colors, like white or light gray, reflect sunlight and help keep your home cooler in the summer. On the other hand, darker colors like black or dark brown absorb more heat, which can help during the cold winter months but may increase cooling costs in the summer.

Many homeowners choose dark roof colors without considering how they will affect their energy bills during the warmer months. A balanced, neutral color like medium gray or tan can offer the best of both worlds, helping your home stay cooler in the summer while retaining heat in the winter.

Pro Tip: Interested in energy-efficient roofing solutions? Learn more here.

2. Not Considering Your Home’s Architectural Style

The architectural style of your home should heavily influence your roof color choice. For example, colonial and traditional homes, which are popular in many New York suburbs, often look best with darker, more neutral tones like slate gray or black. In contrast, more modern or contemporary homes can carry bolder colors like lighter shades of gray, beige, or even metal roofing with subtle color finishes.

Choosing a roof color that doesn’t complement your home’s architecture can make the exterior look disjointed or out of place. A cohesive look that aligns with your home’s style not only enhances curb appeal but can also increase property value. If you're unsure which roof color suits your home best, consider consulting with a professional, like Robertson Roofing, for expert advice.

3. Overlooking the Surrounding Environment

Another common mistake New York homeowners make is neglecting how their roof color will blend with the surrounding environment. This can include the landscape, neighborhood style, and even the seasonality of the area. For example, homes surrounded by trees might benefit from earth-toned roofs that complement the natural surroundings, while urban homes may look better with more modern, neutral shades.

Additionally, don’t forget to consider how your roof will look in different seasons. New York’s fall foliage and winter snow can drastically change how a roof color appears, so make sure your chosen color looks good year-round.

Quick Tip: If your neighborhood follows a certain color scheme or has HOA regulations, make sure your roof color choice aligns with those guidelines.

4. Choosing Based on Trends Rather Than Longevity

While it may be tempting to choose a roof color based on current design trends, it’s important to remember that your roof will be on your home for 20-30 years. A trendy color could look outdated in just a few years, and replacing a roof prematurely is expensive. Instead, opt for timeless colors like gray, brown, or earth tones that will stand the test of time.

Another factor to consider is how different colors age. Darker roofs tend to fade more noticeably than lighter ones, especially under direct sunlight. This can make a trendy dark color look worn out before the roof's lifespan is over. Choosing a roof color that ages gracefully will save you from costly touch-ups or replacements down the line.

5. Ignoring Energy Efficiency and Sustainability

In today’s environmentally conscious world, many homeowners prioritize energy efficiency and sustainability when making home improvement decisions. The color of your roof can greatly affect your home’s energy efficiency. Lighter-colored roofs reflect more sunlight, which can reduce cooling costs during the summer. In contrast, darker-colored roofs absorb heat, which can increase your heating costs in the winter.

For New York homeowners, choosing a color that balances energy efficiency is key. Pairing your new roof with energy-efficient roofing materials or even installing solar panels can further reduce your home’s carbon footprint and energy costs. Robertson Roofing offers eco-friendly roofing options that provide both durability and sustainability.

Interested in energy-efficient roofing options? Check out this guide to see how your roof can help you save.

Final Thoughts:

Choosing the right roof color isn’t just about picking something that looks good—it’s about considering energy efficiency, climate, your home’s architecture, and long-term durability. By avoiding these five common mistakes, you can select a roof color that enhances your home’s value, protects it from New York’s diverse weather conditions, and even lowers your energy bills.

If you’re ready to replace your roof or need guidance on choosing the perfect color, reach out to Robertson Roofing. Our experts will help you make the best choice for your home and ensure the job is done right.